Aplos vs. QuickBooks for Churches: Pricing, Fund Accounting, and Drawbacks
Last updated: November 2026 · Prices verified on Aplos, QuickBooks, and TechSoup pricing pages
Church accounting is different from business accounting. Churches use fund accounting: they track restricted and unrestricted money, report on designated gifts, and show that each fund was used the way donors intended. Most general business software wasn't built for that, which is why the Aplos vs. QuickBooks decision matters for church planters. Here is an honest comparison, including the drawbacks of each and whether you need either one in year one.
Aplos vs. QuickBooks at a Glance
| Criterion | Aplos | QuickBooks Online |
|---|---|---|
| List price | Lite $79/mo · Core $129/mo · Advanced $229/mo | Simple Start $38/mo · Essentials $85/mo · Plus $140/mo · Advanced $340/mo |
| Nonprofit discount | Promotions vary (currently 50% off 3 months on Lite and Core for new customers, through November 30) | Via TechSoup for eligible nonprofits: Plus $80/year, Advanced $170/year |
| Users included | 2 (Lite and Core) | 1 / 3 / 5 / 25 by plan |
| Fund accounting | Native: balance sheet and income statement by fund | Workaround with classes (Plus and above) |
| Donor management and giving | Built in | Not included; pair with a giving platform |
| Bookkeepers who know it | Fewer | Very many |
| Best for | Plants with no accountant on the team that want fund accounting to "just work" | Plants with a QuickBooks-savvy treasurer or bookkeeper, especially with TechSoup pricing |
The Core Issue: Fund Accounting
Standard business accounting asks, "Did we make money?" Church accounting asks, "Did we steward the money according to what we said we'd do?" That requires tracking separate funds (General, Missions, Building, Benevolence) and showing that restricted gifts were used only for their stated purpose. Churches that grow into a financial review or audit will need clean, fund-level records. That single fact shapes this comparison.
Aplos Church Accounting Software
Aplos was built for nonprofits and churches. Fund accounting is native rather than a workaround.
Aplos pricing
- Lite: $79/month, 2 users. Balance sheet and income statement by fund, bank reconciliation, custom reports, board portal, 1099 management, unlimited customer support.
- Core: $129/month, 2 users. Everything in Lite plus basic budgeting, accounts payable and receivable, recurring transactions, period close, third-party integrations, and user roles.
- Advanced: $229/month. Adds budgeting by fund, grant, department, or project, plus dimensional reporting. Custom plans start at $229/month.
Aplos is currently advertising 50% off for three months on Lite and Core for new customers (code YEAREND26, ending November 30), plus a 15-day free trial with no credit card required.
What Aplos does well
- Fund accounting works out of the box, with reports by fund
- Donor records, online giving, and accounting live in one system
- A board portal lets leaders see financials without full access
- Easier for non-accountants to learn
QuickBooks for Churches
QuickBooks Online's strength is ubiquity. Almost every bookkeeper and CPA knows it, so when your volunteer treasurer moves away, finding help is easy.
QuickBooks pricing
- Simple Start: $38/month, 1 user
- Essentials: $85/month, 3 users
- Plus: $140/month, 5 users; includes class and location tracking (the usual fund-accounting workaround)
- Advanced: $340/month, 25 users
Intuit is currently showing 50% off for three months on these plans.
The TechSoup exception: eligible nonprofits can get QuickBooks Online through TechSoup as a donated annual subscription: Plus (5 users) for an $80/year admin fee or Advanced (25 users) for $170/year. Limits: one donated subscription per organization lifetime, an annual renewal fee, and add-ons such as Payroll aren't available through TechSoup. TechSoup decides eligibility, so confirm your church qualifies before you plan around it. If you're still working on IRS recognition, see how to get 501(c)(3) status for a new church.
Fund accounting in QuickBooks: the workaround
- Classes: tag each transaction with a fund class (Plus and above), then run reports by class. It works, but it takes setup, discipline, and someone who understands the limits.
- Separate accounts: track each fund as its own balance-sheet account. This gets messy quickly.
Drawbacks of Each
Every church accounting option has disadvantages. Here they are side by side so you can pick the trade-offs you can live with.
| Aplos | QuickBooks Online | |
|---|---|---|
| Pros | Native fund accounting; donor management and giving built in; board portal; easier for non-accountants; unlimited support included | Every bookkeeper knows it; very low cost through TechSoup; deep reporting; huge integration ecosystem; native payroll add-on |
| Cons | $79/month list price is a real line item for a small plant; only 2 users on Lite and Core; fewer integrations; fewer bookkeepers trained on it | No native fund accounting (classes are a workaround); no donor management; list prices are high without TechSoup; TechSoup excludes Payroll and limits you to one donated subscription |
| Biggest risk | Paying for features you won't use until you have staff, vendors, and multiple funds | Fund reporting that's wrong because classes weren't set up or applied consistently |
Disadvantages of church accounting software in general
- Cost before you need it. A $79–$140 monthly subscription can exceed what a pre-launch plant spends on everything else in software.
- Setup time. A chart of accounts, funds, and bank feeds take hours to configure correctly, and a bad setup produces bad reports.
- Lock-in. Moving years of fund history between systems is painful, so your first choice tends to stick.
- Overlap with your giving platform. If your giving tool already tracks donors and funds, you may be paying twice for the same records.
- It doesn't replace controls. Software won't count the offering or require two signatures; you still need written financial policies.
Do You Even Need Church Accounting Software in Year One?
Often, not on day one. If your plant has one bank account, a general fund plus one or two designated funds, no employees, and fewer than a few dozen transactions a month, a well-built spreadsheet and your giving platform's reports can carry you through launch. Our first-year church budget template shows the line items to track, and the free budget dashboard gives you a working spreadsheet with fund-level totals and a 30-month runway view.
Move to real accounting software when any of these happen:
- You run payroll or pay a pastor through the church
- You hold restricted gifts (building, missions, benevolence) that need to be reported separately
- You pay recurring vendors and need accounts payable
- A sending church, network, board, or lender asks for formal financial statements
- Your volunteer treasurer is spending more than a couple of hours a week reconciling
When you get there, pick the system before you need the reports. Cleaning up 18 months of mixed records is far harder than starting clean.
Our Recommendation
Choose Aplos if:
- You want fund accounting to work correctly without workarounds
- Your treasurer or finance team has limited accounting background
- You want donor management and accounting in one place
- You don't qualify for TechSoup pricing
Choose QuickBooks if:
- Your church qualifies for TechSoup pricing ($80/year for Plus is very hard to beat)
- Your CPA or bookkeeper already knows QuickBooks
- Someone on your team can set up and maintain class-based fund tracking
- You need extensive third-party integrations
The hybrid approach
Some plants use Tithely or Planning Center for giving and donor records, and QuickBooks for bookkeeping. It works with good processes, but you'll need to reconcile the two systems regularly. Not sure which giving platform to pair with it? See our church giving software comparison.
For New Church Plants Specifically
- Simple finances, no staff yet? Start with the free dashboard and your giving platform's reports.
- Qualify for TechSoup? QuickBooks Plus at $80/year, set up with classes for each fund.
- No TechSoup, no accountant? Aplos Lite at $79/month (watch for promotions) is the cleaner choice.
- Bookkeeper already uses QuickBooks? Use QuickBooks. Switching costs aren't worth it.
Free: First-Year Church Budget Dashboard
Not ready for accounting software? Track funds, giving, and 30 months of runway in a pre-built spreadsheet instead.
Get the free dashboard →Sources
- Aplos Pricing Page (checked November 14, 2026)
- QuickBooks Online Pricing (Intuit) (checked November 14, 2026)
- TechSoup: QuickBooks Online for Nonprofits (checked November 14, 2026)
- Aplos: Comparing Aplos vs. QuickBooks for Churches
- QuickBooks for Churches (Intuit)