Church Giving Fees Compared (2026) + Free Fee Calculator
Free: First-Year Church Budget Dashboard
Fees are one line in your first-year budget. Our free Google Sheets / Excel dashboard shows giving, expenses and runway together so you can see what a 2% fee difference actually means.
Get the free dashboard →If you lead a church plant of 0–150 people, giving fees are one of the few costs you can cut without cutting ministry. On $6,000 a month in giving, the difference between the cheapest and most expensive mainstream platforms is more than $4,000 a year. This page puts every major church giving platform's published fees in one table, then lets you plug in your own numbers.
Church giving fees at a glance (November 2026)
Fees verified November 2026 · US pricing| Platform | Card fee (%) | Card fixed fee | ACH / bank | Monthly fee | Donor can cover fees? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zeffy | 0% | $0 | $0 | $0 | Optional tip to Zeffy instead |
| Givebutter (tips on) | 0% to church | $0 | $0 | $0 (Plus CRM from $29/mo, optional) | Yes; Givebutter covers what donors don't |
| Givebutter (tips off) | 3% platform + 2.9% | $0.30 | 3% + 1.9% + $0.30 | $0 | Yes (optional or required) |
| Planning Center Giving | 2.15% | $0.30 | 0% + $0.30 | Free up to 10 gifts/mo; $15 (75), $32 (200), $69 (500) | Yes (US only) |
| Tithely | 2.9% (Amex 3.5%) | $0.30 | 1% + $0.30 | $0 | Yes ("Cover the Fees") |
| Donorbox (Standard) | 2.95% platform + 2.2% Stripe nonprofit | $0.30 | Platform fee capped at $25 + Stripe 0.8% (max $5) | $0 (Pro $150/mo) | Yes |
| Subsplash Giving | 2.3% ("exclusive" rate) | $0.30 | 1% | $0 | Yes |
| Pushpay | 2.1–2.9% (volume-based) | $0.20–$0.30 | 0.5–1.0% + $0.20–$0.30 | Quote only | Yes ("Donor Covers Fees") |
| Stripe (DIY baseline) | 2.9% | $0.30 | 0.8%, max $5 | $0 | Depends on your form |
| PayPal (charity rate) | 1.99% | $0.49 | Not listed for donations | $0 | Depends on your form |
Notes: Subsplash's pricing page also lists 2.99% + 30¢ for "standard cards," so confirm which rate applies to your account. Pushpay doesn't publish a rate card; the range above comes from Pushpay's own blog. Stripe offers a nonprofit discount on request if 80% or more of your volume is tax-deductible donations, and PayPal's 1.99% + $0.49 charity rate needs PayPal's approval first. Neither publishes the discounted Stripe rate on its own pricing page.
Free church giving fee calculator
Enter your expected monthly giving, how much of it comes by card (the rest by bank/ACH), and your average gift. The table re-sorts from cheapest to most expensive as you type. Everything runs in your browser; nothing is sent anywhere.
| Platform | Per month | Per year | Effective rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Turn on JavaScript to use the calculator. With JavaScript off, use the fee table above. | |||
The calculator leaves out Pushpay (no public rate card), American Express surcharges, international cards, text-to-give add-ons and donor-covered fees. If 60% of your givers cover fees, your real cost is roughly 40% of the number shown.
What is the lowest-fee donation software for churches?
On published rates, the cheapest options for the church are the tip-funded platforms: Zeffy and Givebutter with tips turned on. Both charge the church nothing. Zeffy says it covers transaction and card fees and that nonprofits keep 100% of each donation. Givebutter's "Guarantee" covers any processing fees donors choose not to cover when tips are enabled.
Among platforms that charge fees, Planning Center Giving has the lowest published card rate (2.15% + 30¢) and a flat 30¢ ACH fee. ACH is where it really pulls ahead: a $200 bank gift costs 30¢ on Planning Center, $2.30 on Tithely, and $2.00 on Subsplash. The catch is the monthly Giving subscription once you pass 10 gifts a month. In our default example of 80 gifts a month, that's $32 a month.
Using the calculator defaults ($6,000/month, 70% card, $75 average gift, about 80 gifts):
| Platform | Est. monthly cost | Est. annual cost |
|---|---|---|
| Zeffy / Givebutter (tips on) | $0 | $0 |
| Subsplash Giving (2.3% rate) | ~$131 | ~$1,577 |
| Planning Center Giving | ~$146 | ~$1,756 |
| Stripe (standard) | ~$153 | ~$1,836 |
| PayPal (charity rate) | ~$159 | ~$1,903 |
| Tithely | ~$164 | ~$1,966 |
| Donorbox Standard | ~$301 | ~$3,607 |
| Givebutter (tips off) | ~$360 | ~$4,320 |
Is there really free church giving software?
Yes, but "free" means two different things:
- $0 to the church, period. Zeffy and Givebutter (tips on) charge the church nothing. Instead, donors see an optional tip at checkout. Some pastors are fine with that. Others don't like a third-party tip request showing up in the middle of an act of worship. Look at the checkout yourself before you decide.
- $0 per month, fees still apply. Tithely, Subsplash Giving and Donorbox Standard have no subscription, but every gift still pays processing. Planning Center is free up to 10 gifts a month, then moves to a tiered subscription.
For a plant, the tie-breaker usually isn't fees alone. It's whether giving connects to the people database and app you'll use in year two. Tithely and Planning Center both connect giving to a full church management system. Zeffy and Givebutter are general nonprofit tools.
How card vs ACH changes what you pay
Bank (ACH) gifts are much cheaper on most platforms. On a $100 gift:
| Platform | $100 by card | $100 by ACH |
|---|---|---|
| Planning Center Giving | $2.45 | $0.30 |
| Tithely | $3.20 | $1.30 |
| Subsplash Giving | $2.60 | $1.00 |
| Stripe (standard) | $3.20 | $0.80 |
| Donorbox Standard | $5.45 | $3.75 |
Encouraging recurring givers to set up bank transfers is the single biggest fee lever you control. Try moving the "% by card" field from 70 to 40 in the calculator and watch the totals drop.
Should you ask donors to cover the fees?
Almost every platform here lets donors add the fee to their gift. Tithely says about 60% of donors choose "Cover the Fees," and Givebutter cites 92% of donors covering fees when asked. Turn it on, default it to checked if your platform allows, and mention it once from the front. Fee coverage often matters more than the rate gap between two paid platforms.
Which giving platform is best for a church plant?
- Lowest cost, nothing else needed: Zeffy. $0 to the church; it does require donors to see an optional tip.
- Lowest rates plus a free church database: Planning Center Giving, especially if most gifts come by ACH.
- All-in-one with a church-plant offer: Tithely. Free giving, and Tithely advertises its All Access bundle free for a plant's first year (see our free software programs for church plants guide).
- Events, campaigns and giving in one free tool: Givebutter with tips on.
For a feature-by-feature comparison, read our church giving software comparison and Planning Center vs Tithely.
Church giving fee FAQ
Which donation software has the lowest fees for churches?
Zeffy and Givebutter (with tips on) charge the church $0 because donor tips fund them. Among fee-based platforms, Planning Center Giving has the lowest published card rate at 2.15% + $0.30 and charges just $0.30 per ACH gift, plus a monthly subscription after 10 gifts.
Is there free church giving software?
Yes. Zeffy and Givebutter cost the church nothing on a tip-funded model, and Tithely, Subsplash Giving and Donorbox Standard have no monthly fee but still charge processing on each gift. Planning Center Giving is free up to 10 donations a month.
Which church giving options are best for reducing credit card processing fees?
Push recurring givers toward bank/ACH, turn on donor-covered fees, and pick a platform with a low card rate. Planning Center (2.15% + $0.30) and Subsplash (2.3% + $0.30) publish the lowest card rates among church-specific platforms.
How much does Tithely charge per donation?
Tithely charges 2.9% + $0.30 per card gift (3.5% + $0.30 for American Express) and 1% + $0.30 per ACH gift, with no monthly fee for giving. Text-to-give on the free plan is $19 a month.
Does Pushpay publish its fees?
Pushpay does not publish a rate card or subscription prices; its pricing page asks you to request a quote. Its own blog lists card rates of 2.1–2.9% + $0.20–$0.30 depending on total giving volume.
Can a church get Stripe or PayPal nonprofit rates?
Usually yes, but you have to apply. Stripe requires registered nonprofit status, tax documents and at least 80% of volume from tax-deductible donations. PayPal’s 1.99% + $0.49 charity rate needs PayPal’s approval.
What is a good average fee for church online giving?
Using published rates, church-specific platforms like Tithely, Planning Center and Subsplash land between about 2% and 3% of total giving once fixed per-gift fees are included, before donor-covered fees. Run your own numbers in the calculator above, since small average gifts make the fixed 30¢ matter more.
Put your fee estimate into a real budget
Drop the annual fee from the calculator into the free first-year dashboard, alongside rent, insurance and salaries, and see your runway month by month. You can also start from our first-year church budget template.
Get the free dashboard →Sources
- Tithely Pricing (card, ACH, Amex, Cover the Fees, text-to-give)
- Tithely Help Center: Transaction Fees and Subscription Pricing
- Planning Center Giving: processing fees and subscription tiers
- Planning Center Pricing
- Donorbox Pricing (platform and processing fees)
- Donorbox Help: How much does Donorbox cost?
- Zeffy Pricing
- Givebutter Pricing
- Givebutter Help: Standard pricing explained
- Subsplash Pricing
- Pushpay Plans (no public rate card)
- Pushpay blog: church giving platforms for church plants (published rate ranges)
- Stripe US Pricing
- Stripe: Fee discount for nonprofit organizations
- PayPal US Merchant Fees (charity rate)